the ruling requiring fasting and feeding.
God says, “He feeds and is not fed” [al-Anʿam 6:14]. Confirming His intimate friend, He says, “The One who feeds me” [al-Shuʿara 26:79]. He affirmed this without rejecting it. Feeding is a substitute only for an obligation one is capable of performing. There is no obligation here, so no substitute, and thus no feeding.
The constant invocation of one in this station is “There is no strength except through God.” He has no entry into “You alone we ask for help” [al-Fatihah 1:5], nor into the nūn of “we do” or the alif of “I do.”
Of the four added letters[16], however, he has the tāʾ dotted above, with the second-person pronoun, “You do.” He may also have the yāʾ dotted below, “He does,” with the pronoun of identity. Know this. Through God is success.
Continuation on One Who Deliberately Has Intercourse in Ramadan
They agree that he owes making up and expiation.
It is also said that he owes only making up, because the expiation in this instance was not a binding decree, as the circumstances indicate. He, may God bless him and grant him peace, did not command him to fast as a necessity when he lacked the means to free a person or feed, if he was healthy. Had he been ill, he would have told him to fast when he regained health.
Others say
Notes
[16]
(The inward application concerns the imperfect prefixes, nūn, alif, tāʾ, and yāʾ. The author contrasts ascription to the speaker with ascription to the one addressed or the absent third person.)
Translator’s note TN2628-1: The four letters are prefixes of the Arabic imperfect verb, nūn, alif, tāʾ, and yāʾ. First-person ascription is set aside for second- or third-person ascription. The following section begins with an assertion of agreement, then reports other positions, as in the source.
