Judgments of badness and goodness are established only through the revealed Law and purpose (and are therefore relative). Whoever says that good and evil belong to the essence of the good or evil thing is afflicted by ignorance.[180]
Chapter (3.8): The Obligation to Know God
Then he said: If the obligation to know God, and other obligations, requires that future harm be attached to neglecting them, obligation cannot be established through reason, because that is not apprehended by reason.
Chapter (3.9): Sending Messengers
Then he said: If reason is independent in one matter but not in another, there must be an independent means of conveying the latter to it. The sending of messengers is therefore not impossible, and they are the most knowledgeable of creatures concerning ends and paths.
Chapter (3.10): Establishing the Mission of a Particular Messenger
Then he said: If a liar could bring what the truthful person brings, realities would be overturned, power would be replaced by incapacity, and lying would be attributed to the Presence of Might. All this is impossible and the utmost error, given that it has been established that the first one establishes the second in all respects and meanings.
Section Four: On Knowing Disentanglement and Ordering, in the Yemeni Tongue
Chapter (4.1): Restoration
Then the Yemeni rose and said:
Notes
[180]
See Question 51 below.
Translator’s note TN136-1: The final clause of Chapter 3.10 is compressed: the source says that “the first one establishes the second,” without identifying those terms in this clause. The wording is retained rather than supplying an unexpressed conclusion.
