by reason for the soundness of these meanings, although the truthful report from the truthful one has already established the soundness of this wording!
I would like to know: this person who seeks to know God through proof and declares those who do not investigate the proof to be unbelievers—what was his condition before investigating it, and while investigating it? Was he a Muslim or not? Did he pray or fast? Had it been established for him that Muhammad was God’s Messenger to him, or that God existed?
If he believed all this, then his condition was that of ordinary believers: let him leave them as they are and declare no one an unbeliever. If he did not believe it until he investigated and studied dialectical theology, we seek refuge in God from this position, in which defective speculation led him out of faith.
(The Standing of Dialectical Theology and Its Necessity for Scholars)
The scholars of this discipline—may God be pleased with them—did not establish it and write their works in it in order to establish knowledge of God within themselves. They established it to restrain opponents who denied God, the Attributes, some of the Attributes, messengership, the messengership of Muhammad in particular, the temporal origination of the cosmos, the return to these bodies after death, the gathering and resurrection, or related matters. These opponents disbelieved in the Qur’an, called it false, and denied it. The theologians therefore sought to establish proofs against them by the very method they claimed had led them to refute precisely what we affirm as sound, so that they would not unsettle the beliefs of ordinary people.
