As for those who believe that they made it obligatory for their Lord to do so other than what God Almighty mentioned about Himself, then they said that they gave up their boats during the time of increase in order to continue and to prefer the junub that is true in their claim, and if there is a deficiency in that, then it is the same as complete perfection with this consideration. This, in my view, is like what the poet said to Omar ibn Al-Khattab when he was imprisoned

What do you say to chicks with cheerful *** red crops, no water or trees

You threw their earners into the depths of darkness *** So forgive your guide, the King of the people, O Omar

They did not favor you with it, since They presented you to it *** No, but for themselves, the effect would have been

If they had given up their boats out of a divine request,