They unanimously agreed that he must make up for it and perform atonement, and it was said that he is only obligated to make up for it, because the atonement in that was not determined due to the evidence of the circumstances, because he, may God’s prayers and peace be upon him, commanded him, when he did not free himself or feed him, to fast, and it is necessary since he was healthy, and if he had been sick, he would have said to him. If you find health, then fast, and some people say that he only has to make up for expiation, and he does not have to make up for it. What I think is that he does not have to make up for it, and it is desirable for him to make up for it if he is able to do so, and God knows best his ruling on that.